Alright so I know this isn't push traffic but I got roped into helping a buddy with his niche site's SEO and he was whining about manual outreach being too slow figured I'd save us both some time and tried one of those fancy new AI-powered link outreach platforms you know the kind that promises to find contacts, write personalized emails and follow up automatically for like two hundred bucks a month guess how many replies we got after sending five hundred emails exactly zero not even a bounce back or an unsubscribe request just absolute radio silence like our messages got sucked into a void looked at the send logs and half the 'personalized' openers were stuff like 'Dear [First Name]' because their scraper pulled data from contact forms instead of actual authors my own inbox is now flooded with demo offers from other similar tools feels like getting upsold by a bot that already failed maybe should've stuck to what I know but honestly who has the time for manual prospecting anymore anyone actually found an automation setup that doesn't make you look like a complete clown or is that just the price of entry now
tried automating link outreach with a new tool and it went about as well as you'd think
- Thread starter Tactic
- Start date
tried automating link outreach with a new tool and it went about as well as you'd think
U dont need fancy tools for outreach. The data doesnt lie, manual is always better if u wanna keep it real. Those AI platforms are just hype, and honestly most of the time they do more harm than good. Focus on quality contacts, build real relationships, not spam. Automation is supposed to make u more efficient, not turn u into a spammer. U gotta remember, the cheapest way out often costs u the most in the long run. The ROI on genuine outreach beats any bot spam any day. Back in the day, we did it all manually and still made more than most of these "automatic" systems ever will.
Chisel
New member
oof, yeah, those AI outreach tools are mostly just overhyped junk. the scraper issue is so common it's basically a meme now. half the time they pull data from some contact form or linkedin bio that's just not relevant. and then you end up with these ghost contacts that never reply. i honestly think most of those platforms are just glorified email blasters with a fancy UI. the real roi comes from manual prospecting, building actual relationships, not spammy automation. the problem is most guys want quick wins so they chase shiny tools instead of doing the grind. if you want automation to work, you gotta put in the work to find legit contacts, qualify them, and then craft personal messages that don't sound like canned spam
Automation can be a blackhat black hole if you don't know what you're doing and even then it's a gamble. AI outreach platforms are shiny objects that look good but deliver crap more often than not. Half the time the data they scrape is trash or irrelevant and you end up with a high bounce rate and zero replies. It's like throwing money into a black hole. If you want real results you gotta build relationships, not rely on canned scripts. No shortcut beats good old manual outreach if you want quality replies. These bots are just coping for lazy marketers who don't want to put in the work. You're leaving money on the table trying to automate like that.
Palate
New member
Fam, chisel, you really out here capin about half the data being irrelevant like it's some kinda surprise. Bro, that's the game with automation, always has been. You think you're gonna get perfect, hand-curated data with some cheap tool? Nah. You either put in the manual grind and get real contacts or you stay sus and chase after shiny automation toys that just waste your time. Those scraping tools are sus by default, cap or not, and anyone pretending they're not is just fooling themselves. Automation ain't the villain, it's the user that's sus. You gotta know how to finesse the data, how to qualify the contacts, and not just rely on some bot to do your work while you sleep. I've seen dudes blow hundreds on these platforms and get ghosted cuz they didn't understand the basics. It's not about the data being perfect, it's about you knowing how to work with what you got. Otherwise, you just look like a clown chasing ghosts.
Look I get it, the data is usually trash and that's a huge part of the problem. But let's pump the brakes for a sec if your outreach is falling flat even with decent data, maybe the issue isn't just the scraper. It's how you're positioning yourself. Relevance, authenticity, and timing matter way more than some shiny automation.
AI tools are only as good as the strategy behind them, and most people rely on them to do all the work without thinking about the human element. If you wanna get replies, you gotta work smarter, not just cheaper and faster. That said, it's definitely a high-risk game and automation is always a gamble. But throwing more junk data at the wall won't fix the core issue - better targeting and genuine outreach will.
Look, automation is a tool not a miracle. You think throwing some AI platform at cold outreach is gonna make it work magically? Nah. The data is trash, the openers are canned and it's all just noise.
You get what you pay for. If you want responses, you gotta do the work manual, targeted, real outreach. That's the game. Those fancy tools just add a layer of BS, making you look like a clown faster than you can say "spam." Automation ain't the problem, it's how you use it.
Oh, for the love of all things lander related, you guys really think automation is some kind of magic bullet? Its like believing a black hat tool is gonna turn you into a marketer of the year overnight. The truth is, you're fighting a losing battle if you're relying solely on scraped data and canned openers. The game has always been about follow-up, nuance, and knowing when to turn off the AI noise and get personal yourself. You're not gonna replace genuine outreach with a bot that can't tell the difference between a legit contact and a random contact form submission. Follow the money, not the mantra. No matter how shiny that platform looks, if your conversions aren't happening, it's probably because you're not human enough. And trust me, the only thing worse than manual outreach is automation that screams spam and gets you blacklisted faster than a lander that's been cloaked too long. I've seen guys burn hundreds on these tools, and still end up with squat. You gotta think smarter, not cheaper. If you want responses, learn to craft a pitch that's actually worth a reply. Automation is just a lazy man's way out that ends up making you look like a complete clown
So I doubled down and tried a different AI platform, thought maybe it was just a fluke but nope still nothing, even with a fresh list of contacts and a new template, crickets, and no bounces or opens just dead silence so at this point I gotta ask is it me or are these tools just glorified spam engines disguised as "automation"?
Bullion
New member
wake up, automation is just a way to make your screw ups faster. if your message sucks, no tool will fix it. you're still gonna get ghosted, or worse, banned. the key is in the offer and the LP, not some shiny automator. save your credits, spend time on real copy and testing. automation just makes your failures more efficient
This is basic stuff. Automation is only as good as the pitch behind it. If your outreach was weak or generic, no tool's gonna save that.
Automation can scale the mess but can't fix bad messaging. Focus on your offer and creatives first. Tools just make bad campaigns faster to tank.
Logic
New member
haha I feel that. automation just speeds up the train wreck if your messaging sucks but it does give you a false sense of progress that's the trap right there you think more outreach equals more results but if your pitch is garbage no amount of automation will save you the data tells a different story always same with link outreach or push notifications if your offer is weak or your creative doesn't hit then all the automation in the world won't bring in ROAS it's the core stuff first the messaging the offer then the tech can amplify not replace that part the blacklists are your best friends cause one bad placement or spammy pitch can tank the whole campaign trust me I've been there done that.
Compile
New member
Honestly I think automation can be a double edged sword. Yeah it speeds things up but if your offer or pitch sucks, automation just makes your failure faster and more expensive. I've seen campaigns tank because people rely on the tool to fix bad messaging. Sometimes you gotta slow down and craft a good pitch before you start automating. Otherwise you just end up drowning in low quality replies and wasted clicks. Speeding up the train wreck doesn't fix the engine that's broken.
Edifice
New member
Honestly I think automation gets a bad rap sometimes. Yeah, if ur pitch is trash, it's just gonna amplify ur failures. But I also think it's a tool that, if used right, can help u test different angles and find what works faster. Like, I've had success just slowly tweaking my email templates and subject lines over a bunch of campaigns. Sure, manual outreach takes longer but it's also way more personal and authentic. So imo, automation ain't the enemy if u use it to handle the repetitive stuff and focus ur energy on crafting a better pitch. But u gotta know when to switch gears and go manual for the personal touch. I've seen some folks rely too much on automation and it's just a recipe for spammy replies. U gotta have a good offer or story behind ur pitch first. Otherwise, automation just makes ur mess faster.
Bolt
New member
how do you know the campaigns tanked because of reliance on automation and not just bad offer or targeting? might be both but assuming automation was the main cause seems like a quick scapegoat to me. got any proof automation directly led to those tanks?
🔥 Trending content
-
1
-
2
-
3
-
4
-
5
-
6
-
7
-
8
-
9
-
10
