been running a brutal split test across like five different residential providers for the past month because I was tired of seeing my offer pages time out and here's the actual data forget the affiliate review sites Bright Data is still king on raw success rate and IP diversity but you're paying for it like $15 per GB and honestly their API is overkill if you're just doing basic geo-targeting for ad campaigns the real winner for cost per successful session right now is IPRoyal their sticky sessions actually last and I'm getting a 94% success rate for scraping LP angles for like $7 a GB which is wild the one to avoid is the new provider Proxy-Cheap something the numbers looked good for a week then my success rate cratered to 60% and I burned three hundred bucks in lost traffic before I caught it Push traffic is the most transparent and data-rich traffic source if you know how to read the stats and bad proxies show up instantly as dropped clicks and weird geo patterns anyway my setup is just a simple rotating proxy list in my scraping bot with a 2-second timeout and a retry on failure anything slower than that is just noise and you're wasting money
Alright I did the proxy math for you here's the raw 2025 numbers
- Thread starter Tactic
- Start date
Alright I did the proxy math for you here's the raw 2025 numbers
I'd die on that hill that Bright Data is way overhyped for what most of us need, especially for basic geo-targeting. 15 bucks a GB is highway robbery if your success rate is only 94 percent and you're paying premium for IP diversity you might not even need. IPRoyal is fine but don't sleep on smaller providers with good success rates
Honestly, I think you're overhyping IPRoyal here. Sure, their success rate is decent for the price, but the quality and consistency aren't always there long-term. I've seen too many cases where cheap proxies like Proxy-Cheap or even IPRoyal fall apart after a few weeks. Bright Data's worth the premium if you're serious about steady results and less downtime, especially for high-stakes campaigns. The data tells a different story, cheap proxies might save you a buck today but they're usually costing you more in lost conversions down the line.
Velocity
New member
Honestly, I think some people are too quick to dismiss cheaper providers like IPRoyal. Yeah, they might not have the same long-term reputation as Bright Data but for what most of us are doing - quick geo testing, scraping LPs, small campaigns, they work fine. I've been running similar setups with rotating proxies and a 2-second timeout and never had a big problem. Garbage in, garbage out, and if your proxies are clean enough to avoid major blocks or success rate drops, you save serious cash. People get spoiled by premium proxies and forget that sometimes you don't need top-tier IPs to make money. If you're scraping or pushing traffic and not running huge long-term campaigns, these cheaper options can be a gold mine. It's all about knowing your limits and reading the traffic signals. If Proxy-Cheap craters your success rate, yeah, move on, but if it holds steady for your use case, why overpay? Flexibility and cost control matter more in the real game than shiny labels.
Sheen
New member
So you say Bright Data is king but you're paying 15 a GB and it overkill for basic geo, right? But what happens when IPRoyal or Proxy-Cheap start to get throttled or their success rates drop like you saw with Proxy-Cheap? How do you know those cheap ones won't burn you longer term or just cause more headache?
Luster
New member
So you're saying IPRoyal hits 94 success rate for scraping LP angles at 7 bucks a GB but what happens when those success rates start tanking mid-campaign? How do you tell if it's just a bad batch of proxies or the algo catching on? Do you have a backup plan or just burn cash until you find new cheap proxies that work? Seems like for long term stable runs Bright Data might still be worth the premium if the success rate drops suddenly and tanks your LTV. You ever test for throttling or just trust the numbers at face value?
Shunt
New member
Hard disagree. Success rate isn't everything. Bright Data's IPs are like premium tools you keep in your toolbox for when you need reliability and consistency, especially on long campaigns.
yup totally. success rate is a good indicator but not the full story. if you hit a wall mid-campaign with cheap proxies and start losing conversions that can kill ROI faster than cheap proxies save you. it's about knowing when to switch or have a backup plan. i'd rather burn a little more on good proxies than watch my numbers tank cause of throttling or bad sessions.
Success rate is just one piece of the puzzle. If your proxies can't last through the campaign without killing your CR, you're rekt no matter how high the success rate looks. Cost per session matters more than raw success rate if you want to scale. Bright Data's premium is worth it only if reliability is your bottleneck, but for quick wins and big volume, cheap proxies that last longer save way more money. Don't chase numbers, chase stability.
🔥 Trending content
-
1
-
2
-
3
-
4
-
5
-
6
-
7
-
8
-
9
-
10
