right, so i'm usually the one preaching data. here's some. ran a test for a home services client, insurance leads. network promised qualified, verified leads at $45 cpl. i ran 500 clicks from my geo-targeted display traffic, ctr was fine, got 22 leads. all converted on their end. payment date comes, they say 14 of the leads were 'invalid' - wrong phone, duplicates. my tracking shows every lead hit the thank you page with unique ids. their own postback fired. they're trying to pay on 8 leads. that's a 63% invalid rate. lmao, no. anyone else seeing this? i've got the logs and postback data. feels like the old fake loan offer playbook, just with a different vertical. need to know if this is a one-off or a pattern before i burn more budget.
insurance lead gen scam network, numbers don't lie
- Thread starter Bounty
- Start date
insurance lead gen scam network, numbers don't lie
I get where ur coming from but I wouldnt just take the invalid rate at face value. data can be manipulated, especially if they are using different tracking or postback methods to hide the real numbers. 63 percent invalid seems high but it could also be an attempt to inflate the invalids to pay less. dont forget, some networks are masters at making their stats look worse than they actually are. i would dig deeper into their postback logs and compare with ur raw data. never trust just the surface, the data doesnt lie but it can be twisted. be cautious before labeling it a scam, but definitely keep an eye on those patterns.
so they say 14 of the leads are invalid cuz of wrong phone or duplicates but their own postback hit with unique ids? that's a classic sign they're just cherry-picking. if the leads hit the thank you page with different ids but they still claim invalid, that's either a bad tracking setup or they're straight up lying. and if they're lying about the count on the payout, who knows what else is fake.
trust the data that hits your tracker. if you got logs showing everything was unique and valid on your end, their story sounds sketchy as hell. probably just trying to duck out on the payout for the majority of the leads they don't wanna pay. gotta dig into their postback setup and see if they're faking clicks or messing with your data.
Basecamp
New member
Yeah, exactly. They can manipulate the data, switch tracking IDs, do all sorts of crap to hide the real damage. Don't buy into their BS.
Whiplash
New member
Lol, 'don't buy into their BS' like that's a real strategy. Ur just giving them the chance to keep cooking and fudge numbers. Trust but verify is for suckers, my dude.
Credence
New member
Yeah, trust but verify is a joke when they can mess with the data and still expect to get paid. If their postback hits with unique ids but they say invalid, thats a red flag. Find the compromise, dig deeper before throwing more cash at that mess
i get the skepticism but i think some of yall are missing the bigger picture. if their postback fired with unique ids but they say invalid, that's not necessarily a scam. it could be a tracking delay or a lead input error on their end. they might be trying to save face but that doesn't mean it's all fraud. before you burn more budget, dig into the lead data itself, not just the postback logs.
Momentum
New member
yeah but just cuz numbers get shaved doesn't mean they're fake it might be bad creatives or bad traffic but you still gotta respect the data even if it looks sketchy at first keep grinding
okay, so the numbers are true but the question is are they cooked or just the traffic real? in this game, i've seen plenty of fake metrics dressed up as proof, so i don't buy it until i see a stable CR that holds up over time. gotta be cautious, or you end up feeding the scam without even knowing.
Forge
New member
That line's not 'accurate'. Numbers only show what they're fed. If the source is shady or the traffic's contaminated, those numbers are just noise.
Don't trust 'em blindly. Always cross-check with your own data and look for anomalies. If it looks too clean or too volatile, it's probably lying. In lead gen, trust your eyes and your gut more than just a dashboard
🔥 Trending content
-
1
-
2
-
3
-
4
-
5
-
6
-
7
-
8
-
9
-
10
