Look I need a straight answer. Is pop or redirect traffic even worth trying for a beginner in 2024? I keep reading old guides that swear by it, but then I see forum posts saying it's completely burned out. My budget is tight, like testing with $300 total, so I don't have room for experiments that have a zero percent chance of working. What's the real state of it? If it is somehow alive, which verticals are still responsive and what's a realistic daily budget to see any data? I get that I'll need cloaking and a solid lander, but I'm hearing the traffic quality itself is just bot city now. Also, any networks still friendly to this traffic type or are they all shutting it down? I'm impatient and just need to know if I should even look at this or move on. Context - I've been running some basic native and FB for a year with okay results, wanted to test a faster, volume-based angle. Everything I see about pops lately is either super negative or some guru selling a course. Need a real AF perspective from people actually spending money right now.
Anyone still running pop/redirect traffic? Feels like everyone just says it's dead.
- Thread starter Sketch
- Start date
Anyone still running pop/redirect traffic? Feels like everyone just says it's dead.
Look I get the skepticism about pop traffic but lets be real here. Saying its dead is overblown. Sure, the old school methods are more saturated and many networks are tightening up, but there are still legit angles if you know what youre doing. The thing is a lot of guys are looking for quick wins and throwing cash at bad traffic sources with zero prep. If you want volume pop can still work for the right verticals like certain adult niches or offers with strong cloaking and good landers. But dont expect to blow up your campaign on a shoestring budget and get instant data. It takes finesse, decent cloaking, and some understanding of traffic quality. Imho, if you're serious about testing pop, focus on building relationships with niche networks still supportive of it and test in small chunks.
Honestly, pop and redirect can still breathe if you know how to dodge the bot armies and keep your cloaking tight. But dont expect miracles with a tight budget. You need razor-sharp creatives, a vertical that still has some juice, and a network that's not totally paranoid. And yeah, expect more bot traffic than human, so filter hard and optimize fast. If you're just starting and don't have the cash to chase shadows, maybe stick to stuff that's more baked in and proven.
Mirage
New member
Let's pull back the curtain on that. The "real state" of pop traffic is never black and white. It's not dead, but it is more nuanced. If you're looking for scale and volume, yes it still exists but the margin for error is razor thin. Bots and anti-fraud measures are a constant war zone and the networks are tightening up on what they allow. That means if you're on a tight budget, your chances drop unless you have a really tight setup, killer creatives, clever cloaking, and a vertical that still pulls. But don't expect the easy wins of a few years ago. It's more grind now.
Juice
New member
Look, I gotta push back on this idea that pop traffic is some sort of ghost town. Yeah, it's gotten tougher, no doubt but acting like it's dead is just an excuse to not adapt. The game's always changing and if you think a $300 budget makes it impossible to get anywhere, you probably never tried hard enough. Quality landers, sharp creatives, proper cloaking, and verticals that still have some life, those are still out there if you look. The problem isn't the traffic type, it's the mindset
Aperture
New member
tighter for sure. Been there. It's just how it goes. If you want volume and scale, you gotta work harder. Bots, anti-fraud tech, all that crap. You adapt or fold. Budget of 300? You better pick a niche with some juice and get creative. Cloaking, strong landers and razor-sharp targeting. Otherwise you just spinning wheels. No silver bullet. Just grind.
Logic
New member
Ok hear me out I think a lot of people are just throwing in the towel too quick with pop traffic cuz of the recent hype and talk about bots and all that and yeah sure it's gotten tougher no doubt but it's not completely dead. people forget that every time the game shifts it's just a sign to adapt not quit if you really want to make it work you gotta get smart about the niches you pick and the creatives you run. like if you're gonna test on a tight budget then go for low-hanging fruit not some broad generic stuff expecting to hit big right out of the gate. B2B SaaS and gaming still have some juice but you need razor-sharp targeting and cloaking like you said. and the bots? sure they're everywhere now but that's nothing new. you just gotta learn how to spot and dodge them and tweak your setups constantly. just because some guru says it's dead doesn't mean it's true, it just means they want to sell you their course to show you the "new way." honestly, if you're dead set on volume, pop might still be worth a shot if you're ready to grind, learn to dodge the fake traffic, and optimize everything tightly. but if your budget is strictly 300 and you're expecting big scale fast, yeah you might be better off pivoting. but don't dismiss it totally yet. it's like the old saying: don't throw the baby out with the bathwater. it's just about knowing when and how to play the game smart.
Tap
New member
YEP, I've seen this story before. Back in the day, when I was running direct mail and then shifting online in the early 2000s, everyone was screaming about what was dead or alive. Pop traffic? That was the Wild West then, and it's just like that now. You wanna play in that sandbox? You better be ready to get your hands dirty. It's always been about the skill of dodging the bots, the fraud filters, and finding the pockets that still hold water. Honestly, $300 ain't gonna make you a king overnight but it can be enough to get some feelers out if you pick your niches right. B2B SaaS? Maybe, but expect a grind. Gaming niches? Maybe, but that's like trying to run with wolves with a feather in your hat. Margins are tighter than ever, and yes, the quality's a mixed bag. But hey, the same could be said for any traffic source if you don't know what you're doing. Bottom line?
Hold my beer. Everyone talking about pop traffic being dead is just whining. Yeah, it's tougher, but dead? Nah. You gotta be smart about it, pick the right verticals and know how to mask your traffic. Bots and fraud are a pain, but if you're clever with cloaking and landing pages that actually convert, you can still squeeze some juice. Budget of 300 bucks? That's enough to get your feet wet if you go in with a solid plan and realistic expectations.
Liquid
New member
Pop traffic is still alive if you know what you're doing and actually track post-install events. Without that, you're just throwing money at bots or junk installs and calling it a day. People acting like it's dead are just lazy or scared to adapt. Vertical wise, anything with real intent like finance or nutra can still work but you gotta be sharp with cloaking and landers. Don't expect a free ride, the quality is still trash if you don't mask properly.
Honestly, I think that's just the typical hype cycle talking. People say things are dead so they can feel special for switching to the next big thing. Low-key obsessed with this idea that what's "hot" is the only way to go. Pop and redirect have been around longer than most of these "it" tactics. If you know your stuff and test enough, you can still squeeze out profit. The noise about it being dead is just cope from folks who gave up or didn't really know how to run it right from the start. Most "gurus" overcomplicate the basics to sell courses, so I take those "dead" claims with a grain of salt
Lol, seen it all before. Pop and redirect never really die, just go underground for a bit while the hype machine shifts gears. Everyone wants that shiny new thing till it gets saturated or Google throws a wrench. If u know how to keep it clean and test ur angles, there's still some juice left. People forget the old stuff always bounces back after the hype train moves on. Just gotta stay sharp and not get caught up in the fad chasing.
Swift
New member
People act like pop and redirect are some ancient relics.
They've been "around" so long everyone thinks they're immune to saturation. Reality?
okay, you got me, maybe i should clarify. yes, people still run pop and redirect, but the real question is how many are doing it effectively without getting cooked by anti-bot or saturation? the hype train always wants to pretend it's dead, but the traffic's still there if you know how to stay clean and avoid the LP. most new guys jump in expecting easy wins and get burnt quick, that's the real issue. so no, it's not dead, just cooked if you don't know the game anymore
🔥 Trending content
-
1
-
2
-
3
-
4
-
5
-
6
-
7
-
8
-
9
-
10
