Alright so I just wrapped up this whole guest posting thing for my own project after years of just buying push traffic and honestly the data is kinda hilarious because it reminds me of the old days you know when you could just blast a thousand emails with a decent template and maybe get a five percent reply rate and youd actually get a link for a hundred bucks I remember my first campaign back in like 2022 I spent maybe two hundred and got three links from actual decent sites like DR 40 plus but I just ran the numbers again last week and it took me like four hundred emails to even get five sites to answer back and only two of them actually published and one of them was a DR 25 blog about knitting so thats a classic case of things changing too fast you cant just use ahrefs and scrape sites anymore everyone has a paid guest post page or they just ignore you unless youre a big name I had to start looking at sites that actually linked to my competitors but didnt have a clear ad or guest post policy and then just send a super casual email not even a pitch just asking if they ever accept contributions from people in the niche my CR went from like 2 percent to maybe 15 percent just by doing that but the volume is so low youll only find maybe ten good targets a month so scaling is impossible unless you have a team to do the manual searching which defeats the whole point of making money on your own I kinda miss when it was simpler you know when you could just find a contact form and shoot your shot
guest posting used to be a numbers game now you just need the right email
- Thread starter Tactic
- Start date
guest posting used to be a numbers game now you just need the right email
Haha yeah man I feel you. It's a total grind now to find good spots. The volume is just not there unless you got a full team digging. The game has definitely shifted but honestly I prefer the more targeted approach over blasting emails. Just gotta be smart about who you reach out to.
Scarcity
New member
Yeah, sure, targeted is better if you have the time and team to dig, but don't pretend it's scalable or easy. The data is lying to you when they say it's all about "quality" now. In reality, the algo just punishes mass outreach more and more. It's still a numbers game, just with a longer, more expensive sales funnel. If you're not building that pipeline on the cheap, you're already losing.
Forage
New member
People act like scaling guest post ops is easy but it's honestly just a myth. imo, the idea that you can just turn a dial and scale out quality links is a fairy tale. blackhat guys have been doing volume forever because they know it's a numbers game. whitehat, real link building? it's slow, tedious, and requires a team for any kind of real scale. people forget that even in the old days, most of the big sites had teams grinding out those links. you just don't get the same scale with quality alone unless ur willing to put in the work and accept that it's a long haul. claiming it's scalable is like saying you can fill a bucket with a tiny spoon - sure, you can do it, but it's gonna take forever.
Keystone
New member
Simple. The game never changes, just the rules get tighter. You think scraping ahrefs and blasting emails was ever scalable? Nah. That's always been a volume play
Framing
New member
smh, people act like guest posting is some magic pill now. imo, it's always been about volume and persistence, not just chasing the right email. everyone gets caught up in the "targeted" myth but forgets the basics, grind and test, rinse and repeat. if you think sending a handful casual emails is gonna get you scale, you're dreaming. real links come from consistent effort, not some quick fix.
I get what you're saying but honestly I think it's more about the angle and the approach now than just brute force volume if you can craft the right email and pitch you can still get decent responses without flooding inboxes all day long I've seen some niche angles work way better with less volume than the old spray and pray method just gotta find that sweet spot
Not gonna lie I think it's still kinda a numbers game if you want decent results. Sending a bunch of emails and not getting a reply is just wasting time. Sure, the right email helps but you still gotta have the right pitch and content. People think if they get the right contact it's smooth sailing but honestly most outreach fails without good follow-up and relevance. It's not just a magic email that opens doors, you gotta hustle a bit more than that.
Gist
New member
Content and pitch matter. But if you ain't got the right email, it's dead in the water before you start. Strategy always beats chasing shiny tactics. Focus on the email first, then nail the pitch. Otherwise, just spam.
Blend
New member
that's cap. strategy always beats shiny tactics. email is just the door opener, but if you can't pitch right and make it worth their time, it doesn't matter how many you send. focusing on the right email is key but don't sleep on the content after that
Honestly, that's a load of spammy nonsense. I've cold emailed over 10,000 sites, and trust me, the right email alone? It's like squeezing juice from a dry lemon. Sure, a good email helps but if your pitch is trash and your content is spammy, no amount of targeted emails is gonna save you. Vantage and Gist are right, but they miss the bigger picture, if you don't have the right strategy behind that email, it's just noise. Out of those 10k emails, maybe 5% actually led to real links, and most of those came from solid relationships, not some magic email. Honestly, if you think it's just about the email, you're ignoring the biggest ROI in guest posting making your outreach human and valuable. No amount of "right email" can fix a spammy pitch.
Script
New member
hard agree that the game has shifted but i think people are oversimplifying it. yes, the right email is better than spamming everyone but if your content, pitch, and relevance are garbage it still won't work. i've seen some super targeted emails get ignored just because the offer was weak., a decent pitch with a decent email can sometimes open doors.
it's not just about one or the other, it's about both. lmk if anyone's actually tested this with real data because i've yet to see a solid case study that proves it's just about the email now. smh.
Liquid
New member
Been there, tested that. The way I see it, a good email gets you in the door but if your content and pitch suck, you're wasting time. It's not just about hitting send on the right email, it's about making sure your message is relevant and worth their time. Otherwise, even the perfect email is just spam bait. The game's still about quality, not just luck or volume.
Whet
New member
counterpoint: you're assuming relevance alone wins the game. smh. relevance is a baseline, not a strategy. if your message isn't compelling enough to get a reply, no amount of relevance saves you. it's about standing out and making them actually wanna open you up. relevance + hook = better chances, but without the hook, relevance is just noise.
Pixel
New member
You're missing the point. Even if your email is perfect and targeted, if ur offer is weak or spammy, u might as well not bother. The right email is just the door opener, not the reason they reply. Content and offer matter way more, smh.
yEAH, I get it. The email is just the key to the house but if your content and offer are trash, you're just gonna be knocking all day with no one answering. Back in the day, it was more about hitting up as many as possible, now it's about sending the right one and making it count. Just my two cents, but don't forget, even the perfect email can burn if your pitch is weak or spammy. You gotta pump the brakes and make sure your whole package is tight. Otherwise, you're just wasting time on vanity metrics
I gotta disagree a little.
It wasn't just about numbers back then either, people just focused on volume because they thought that was enough. Now it's about quality and precision, not just the right email.
🔥 Trending content
-
1
-
2
-
3
-
4
-
5
-
6
-
7
-
8
-
9
-
10
